Little Italy’s Alleva Dairy faces closure due to pandemic

That’s a whole lot of cheese!

A Manhattan deli billed because the oldest cheese retailer within the US is in jeopardy of closing due to $509,106 price of lease it didn't pay through the COVID-19 pandemic.

First established in 1892, Alleva Dairy at 188 Grand Avenue has been sued by its landlord for allegedly owing the again lease over the previous few years.

The month-to-month lease below the Little Italy store’s lease is $23,756, in response to courtroom data.

The swimsuit filed in Manhattan Supreme Courtroom by the owner Jerome G. Stabile III Realty asks for “permission to evict you from the topic premise if you don't pay the cash judgment.”

Alleva additionally suffered from the closure of close by eating places, which commonly spent 1000's of dollars month-to-month on its yummy Italian cheeses, akin to mozzarella, provolone and ricotta, mentioned its present proprietor, Karen King.

“Alleva has been in a battle for its life the previous 2 1/2 years,” King mentioned.

King and her husband John “Cha Cha” Ciarcia — a relative of the founding Alleva household with roots in Benevento, Italy — purchased the fromage manufacturing facility in 2014 to maintain it in enterprise.

Alleva Dairy is located at 188 Grand Street in Little Italy NYC.
Alleva Dairy is positioned at 188 Grand Avenue in Little Italy NYC.
Christian Johnston

Ciarcia, the “unofficial mayor of Mulberry Avenue” and visitor actor on “The Sopranos” who had introduced in actor-pal Tony Danza as a accomplice in Alleva, died in 2015.

Karen King assumed full possession of the enterprise when he handed.

“Tony may bail us out however I’m not asking him to bail us out,” King mentioned of Danza.

At a courtroom listening to Friday, she and her lawyer, Domenick Napoletano, proposed a gouda plan — providing to instantly put up $250,000 and repay the remaining debt over the length of the lease.

Salamis hang from ceiling at Alleva Dairy on corner of Grand and Mulberry Streets is the Oldest Italian Cheese Store in America.
Alleva’s landlord filed a lawsuit towards the cheese retailer homeowners asking for “permission to evict you from the topic premise if you don't pay the cash judgment.”
VWPics through AP Photographs

However the landlord’s lawyer refused the provide, King’s lawyer mentioned.

“It’s ridiculous. Most landlords would conform to that proposition,” Napoletano mentioned.

King added, “I poured my life financial savings into Alleva. I’m not strolling away from it. We purchased Alleva to put it aside.”

She mentioned the landlord is refusing to have in mind the devastating influence the lingering pandemic had on Alleva, in addition to different companies in Little Italy. One neighborhood mainstay, Forlini’s restaurant, just lately introduced it was closing for good after 79 years in enterprise.

Cheese at Alleva's display window.
Little Italy has shrunk lately, partly as a result of rising rents and demographic modifications.
Christopher Sadowski for NY Publish

“There have been no vacationers in Little Italy through the pandemic. There was no one coming right here. Nobody anticipated the pandemic to go on that lengthy,” King mentioned.

Throughout her tenure, King mentioned she up to date Alleva’s web site and expanded take-out and catering service to attempt to compensate for the lack of foot site visitors.

“Thank god. I received a whole lot of new clients,” she mentioned.

Earlier than COVID, King deliberate to increase the premises and open a café on the nook of Grand and Mulberry streets. She additionally constructed a brand new kitchen and employed a chef to supply extra meals and was engaged on a branding and distribution plan when the well being disaster floor the Large Apple to a halt.

Cheese and tins of olive oil at Alleva Dairy on corner of Grand and Mulberry Streets is the Oldest Italian Cheese Store in America,
Karen King mentioned she isn’t giving up on Alleva regardless of the lawsuit.
Chuck Pefley / VWPics through AP Photographs

Alleva now sells baked bread with broccoli rabe, meatloaf, rooster marsala, lasagna and pasta dishes, together with spaghetti carbonara, amongst different Italian delicacies.

“We’re combating to get a while to pay up,” she mentioned. “That’s all we’re asking for.”

Ellen Stabile Bench, whom King recognized because the landlord-owner of the realty agency, informed The Publish, “I actually don’t want to speak to you.”

Little Italy has shrunk lately, partly as a result of rising rents and demographic modifications.

In the meantime, Italian-American civic activists have complained that New York’s elected officers have neglected Little Italy in comparison with its rising neighbor, Chinatown. They criticized the awarding of a $20 million grant for Chinatown that made no point out of Little Italy.

In a gesture of fence-mending, Gov. Kathy Hochul just lately introduced the award of a $1 million grant to assist full building of the brand new Italian-American Museum on Mulberry Avenue.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post