Officer Olivia Dengler allegedly lied throughout her CCRB listening to concerning the false arrest of a person police stopped whereas getting off an specific bus.
Youtube
Scores of NYPD officers lied throughout disciplinary proceedings over the previous 10 years, with most getting off scot-free or with a slap on the wrist — and a few had been even later promoted, in keeping with a brand new report.
In all, 181 Massive Apple cops had been caught fibbing to the Civilian Grievance Evaluate Board, however 80 weren't disciplined in any respect, 43 simply misplaced trip days and 42 had been solely subjected to directions or command self-discipline, nonprofit civil rights group Latino Justice stated within the report launched Monday.
Solely 4 of the officers had been suspended and a dozen resigned or have pending circumstances.
“Practically one-half of the officers who lied to the CCRB had been by no means disciplined in any respect, even for the underlying misconduct they lied about,” stated the report, titled “Shielded from Accountability.”
“The NYPD’s refusal to behave when its officers lie has critical ramifications,” it stated. “Officers who obtain no penalties for mendacity will proceed to take action. People who're by no means advised that an officer testifying towards is called a liar can not obtain truthful trials.”
One egregious instance was the CCRB probe of Officer Eric Rodriguez, who was investigated for slamming a suspect towards a subway turnstile in 2011 — with each Rodriguez and his accomplice later discovered to have lied to cowl their tracks.
Amaury Munoz advised the unbiased police watchdog that he dozed off on the forty second Road subway station on Oct. 30, 2011, and was roused from his sleep by the 2 cops.
Munoz testified on the listening to that the cops ordered him to go away the station, however when he did so, they advised him, “You’re not strolling fast sufficient.”
Munoz stated Rodriguez then “actually grabbed and pushed and threw me into the turnstile.
“I used to be picked up and dragged by [Rodriguez] and thrown by way of the emergency door for a second time,” he stated on the listening to. “I used to be helpless.”
After the incident, he stated he was “bleeding profusely” and chipped his entrance tooth.
Rodriguez stated they requested Munoz to go away the station after getting a report of an intoxicated particular person there, and that he turned combative and hit the turnstile.
However surveillance footage from the station confirmed Munoz’s model of the incident — though the veteran cop “clarified” his story after being proven the movies.
In its findings, the CCRB discovered the cop’s use of pressure “pointless and extreme.”
The board beneficial that Rodriguez be suspended for 26 days for the incident.
His accomplice, who was additionally discovered to have lied to the board, was by no means disciplined.
However that was hardly the one instance cited by the Latino Mission.
Officer Bernie Garcia was accused of harassing a motorist and refusing to offer his identify throughout a Might 2011 visitors cease in Brooklyn, the report stated.
Garcia and his accomplice had been caught in a lie when the driving force’s mobile phone video of the incident surfaced, and Garcia was docked 40 trip days.
He has since been promoted to sergeant.
In 2015, three different cops — Sergeant David Cussen and Officers Cory Smith and Daniel Tune — had been accused of approaching a person exterior a Flushing US Marine Corps recruiting station with out trigger and frisking him.
Additionally they frisked two Hispanic males who had been talking with the recruiter.
All three males lied concerning the incident and had been docked trip days.
Two different officers had been questioned for arresting a person in March 2018 after accusing him of being a drug seller when he was merely sitting on a milk crate.
The person left the scene however was confronted by the officers — Christopher Cianicullo and Vasyi Fischukov — 4 days later exterior his constructing, the report stated.
In line with the CCRB, Cianicullo “forcibly” grabbed the person whereas he had his son sitting on his shoulder, sending each tumbling to the bottom.
The officers denied the account however had been caught red-handed on surveillance video.
A choice on self-discipline for Cianicullo remains to be pending, however no motion was taken towards Fischukov, who has since been promoted to sergeant.
The NYPD didn't instantly reply to a request for remark.
Post a Comment