Carol Ivanick's son claims she is withholding uncommon baseball playing cards she purchased him many years in the past.
A Manhattan man is doing what each American male has most likely contemplated — suing his mommy over the lack of beneficial baseball playing cards.
Christopher Trencher mentioned the playing cards — a 1953 Topps Ralph Kiner and a 1953 Topps Satchel Paige — are price greater than $25,000, if his mother, Carol Ivanick, hasn’t broken them.
Ivanick, now 82, allegedly purchased Trencher the playing cards as a present within the mid Nineteen Eighties, however has refused at hand them over regardless of his repeated requests, he claimed in his Manhattan Supreme Court docket submitting.
The playing cards are “uncommon and irreplaceable,” Trencher, 55, a prime backgammon participant, mentioned in his litigation.
The mother was as befuddled by the authorized motion as a batter attempting to hit a Jacob De Grom slider.
“Are you severe? He filed a case in opposition to me in Manhattan Supreme Court docket?” mentioned the incredulous Ivanick, a lawyer and mother of three, when The Publish requested in regards to the allegations.
Ivanick insisted her son gave the playing cards to her as a present within the mid- Nineties.
“I used to be a giant fan of Satchel Paige. I’m in my 80s and nonetheless having fun with them,” she mentioned of the playing cards, noting she retains them in protecting acrylic holders, locked in a secure and takes them out to have a look at them each few weeks.
“I used to be very happy he was together with me in his passion, and Satchel Paige was an iconic determine for me.”
Corridor of Fame pitcher Paige was the primary African-American to pitch within the World Sequence; Kiner, a Corridor of Famer slugger who performed for the Pittsburgh Pirates, was a beloved broadcaster for the New York Mets.
If the playing cards are in “gem mint” situation, they are often price $30,000, mentioned Chris Ivy, director of sports activities for Heritage Auctions.
Of practically 3,300 Topps Satchel Paige playing cards from 1953 graded for public sale, solely eight have been discovered to have that degree of high quality, he famous.
Like numerous different child collectors, Trencher saved baseball playing cards at his mother’s home for years, however not like many, “he got here and received all of them,” she mentioned.
She known as the authorized motion “very unhappy.”
“I wish to get pleasure from them with no matter years I've left. I’m 82 years previous, they're positively mine, he gave them to me,” she mentioned.
Ivanick mentioned she hasn’t spoken to her son or his household in a few years after a falling-out she refused to element.
“They banished me from the household some time again. They received’t let me see my grandchildren, received’t let me see anyone there,” she mentioned.
“I suppose he’s determined that is the best way to get the cash for himself,” mentioned Ivanick, who mentioned she’s already written the Kiner and Paige playing cards into her will as a bequest for Trencher’s kids.
Trencher, who refused to remark, desires a choose to pressure his mother at hand over the playing cards or pay what he says they’re price: $25,000.
Post a Comment